Let us not vilify the Detroit doctor as we work to end Female Genital Cutting

By: Anonymous

Country: United States
Age: 34

Shortly after my seventh birthday, I went to visit my grandmother in New York. My mother told me this visit was going to be special because I turned seven and I had to have something “important done”.  “All girls have to have it done when they turn seven,” I was told, just as my older sisters had it done before me.  My mother said it was to ensure a “good marriage” when I am older. At the age of seven, this was a more than sufficient explanation for me. I just took this explanation as the norm, and even believed that women of all faiths and cultures must undergo the same experience. At the time, I had no idea that day would be life-changing for me on so many levels.  

The procedure harmed me physically. It was, unsurprisingly, botched, being conducted on a basement floor by an untrained older housewife in our community. But the message I was told that day – “this will help your marriage”, and messages I was subsequently told throughout my life “this is to make sure women’s urges are controlled”, “these things are done to make sure you are loyal to your husband”, “women need to appease their husband” – these messages are what truly did the most psychological harm. These messages have caused me to live a life in which I felt inferior to my partner and felt shame for all my natural urges/feelings.  

As I grew more aware of how that day impacted me, I became upset and resentful. I was angry about what I was forced to go through and constantly wondered what would have been if that day never happened. Thinking about other little girls, who would undoubtedly have to undergo the same thing, overwhelmed me with feelings of anger, sadness, and helplessness. I hoped people in our community would stop subjecting innocent girls to this practice. I wished people would wake up and realize they were doing more harm than good – that they were truly doing no good at all.  

A few days ago news broke of a female doctor in Detroit who was charged with illegally performing FGM on two young girls. My first reaction – like that of many who are opposed to this practice was a feeling of vindication. Someone was finally being held responsible for this practice. People might start becoming aware that this is a serious problem, not just abroad, but right here in the US. I also thought this case might act as a deterrent for many other people who are thinking of performing FGC.

After witnessing people’s reaction to the news, my vindication soon turned into disheartenment. People adamantly opposed to the practice or adamantly opposed to Islam, began to vilify this doctor as a cruel heartless sexual predator. But that is not what I saw in her. I just saw a woman, just like my mother, aunt, or grandmother. A woman – a mother who was trying to do what was best.

My mother did not take me for that procedure with some malicious intent to hurt me. She did so, in the same manner, many of us take our children for immunizations, needed surgeries, or even male circumcisions. It hurts us to subject our children to anything painful, but we do so with the firm believe that it is being done in their best interest. We put faith in our medical professional’s guidance because they are widely respected and trusted as experts in a field. Similarly, people living in a Bohra community – those constantly surrounded by those of similar faith – put their faith in the guidance of their religious leaders. In their world, these leaders are widely accepted as trusted “experts” who know what is best for each one of us. For them, the divine rules set forth by these leaders well supersede standards set by medical communities or politicians.  

So I look at this woman and I don’t see a villain – I see a victim. A victim like myself who has undoubtedly also been unjustly cut as a child. A woman who was not only physically abused in the past but also continues to be mentally manipulated into acting against her better judgment. I am not completely absolving her from the choices she made – everyone must take responsibility for their actions, and she could have acted differently. I am just attempting to explain, from the perspective of her world, how it often might seem like there is no choice for her to do otherwise.  

So by villainizing her, punishing her – you may scare some other doctors from conducting the practice. You may deter some other mothers from having their children undergo the procedure. But punishing her does not punish the true abusers. As long as the male leaders continue to advocate for this practice and maintain its importance in religious doctrine, followers will continue to adhere to the guidance of their respected leaders. My worst fear is that this public case mixed with continued pro-FGC messaging from our community will drive this practice underground even more. So instead of having doctors illegally practice in their sanitized clinics after hours – our girls will be subjected to experiences similar to mine – being cut by their grandmothers on an unsanitary cold basement floor.  

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Let us not vilify the Detroit doctor as we work to end Female Genital Cutting

  1. HLC

    Dr. Jumana Nagarwala should be punished to the full extent of the law. She knew what was doing was illegal and she is now lying about her actions (https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2017/04/27/three-indicted-female-genital-mutilation-michigan/307021001/). It is not helpful to the eradication of FGM to condemn the practice as heinous and abusive from one side of your mouth and defend a highly-educated professional who subjected children to it from the other side. I agree that the male Bohra leaders who advocate for FGM have the blood of young girls on their hands – but their influence must be stopped culturally, by Bohra members standing up against them. Horrible as their actions are, these men did not break US law – Dr. Nagarwala did, and she now must answer for it.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. DILSHAD TAVAWALLA, Barrister, Solicitor, Notary Public - Toronto, Canada

    I agree with the above comment.

    The three American Dawoodi Bohra (Dr. Jumana Nagarwala, Dr. Fakhruddin Attar and Farida Attar PhD), perpetrators – and human and child rights’ violators charged in the Detroit FGM case are as, if not more, sophisticated and educated than the 3 Australian Dawoodi Bohras A2 (the mother of 2 minor girls), Kubra Magennis (retd. nurse) and Sheikh Mohammadbhai Vaziri (Sydney Amil) – convicted of committing crimes involving, inter alia, the commission of FGM.

    The Australian and US (Detroit) cases brought to the fore facts and allegations about the bold and blatant manner in which the dark, hidden crime(s) relating to the perpetration of FGM are committed, not just in back rooms of houses and homes, but in clinics as well.

    These are highly placed individuals, holding positions of authority, respect and trust within the DB community, and the community at large. They are/were vested with knowledge, power and authority, both personal and professional, and are/were required to carry out their duties of protecting and attending to the welfare of people they serve, particularly, vulnerable and trusting children who obey and look up to them (as parents and doctors) due to the authority and power they wield.

    So please, stop this hypocrisy and double-speak. Dr. Nagarwala is a ‘Made in USA’ product. She is born in the USA, educated and practices medicine with its states. Dr. Fakhruddin Attar and his spouse, Farida Attar, are equally, and also educated in USA, and have more smarts which average citizens or lay person in any other part of the world.

    According to her Linkedin Profile, Farida Attar is a Ph.D. in Microbial Ecology.:

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/farida-attar-7528bb15/

    Why should the rights of fairness and due process of these overly sophisticated and over-educated adults be upheld, and the human and child rights of the trusting, hapless, vulnerable minor Dawoodi Bohra girls whom they allegedly violated, and failed to protect be ignored?

    And why should child protection services and FBI not question, and expand their probe to include the daughters of these 3 Dawoodi Bohra US citizens who have been indicted?

    Who is speaking out, and representing interests of these innocent girls?

    The responsibility falls on the state, and therefore, the state is clothed with certain powers to serve and protect them, and the state through its agencies –
    child protective agencies & services, police forces, FBI will, and should, in my opinion, assert those powers.

    Like

  3. Pingback: How Muslim Activists Are Working To Finish Feminine Genital Mutilation In The U.S. - News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s